Skip to main content

GP who circumcised boy without father's OK can keep working

A UK tribunal found no misconduct by a Nottingham GP who circumcised a boy, 7, without his father's consent. He can keep practicing.

A Plastibell, the small plastic ring with a string used in one circumcision method, on a black background

Photo: Dan Bollinger / Wikimedia Commons · CC BY-SA 4.0

A UK medical tribunal has cleared a Nottingham family doctor of misconduct over the circumcision of a 7-year-old boy whose father did not know about it, the BBC reported.

The Medical Practitioners Tribunal Service found on Monday, after two weeks of hearings, that the General Medical Council (GMC), the UK's medical regulator, had not proved its allegations against Dr. Balvinder Mehat. The panel was satisfied that he had asked who had parental responsibility for the boy, known as Patient A, "and was told directly that Ms C [the mother] was the only one."

"The allegations against me were originally made in 2022, I am relieved that this case is now over and my name has been cleared," Mehat said in a statement to the BBC. "As a GP of many years I am and have always been dedicated to patient care," he said in his statement.

The boy was circumcised on October 19, 2022, at Bakersfield Medical Centre in Nottingham, England. His parents had married in 2019 and were still married, though separated, at the time. The mother wanted it done for "spiritual and cultural reasons," the tribunal was told. She had not named the father on the boy's birth certificate or on the consent form she signed.

Earlier in the hearing, the tribunal heard that the father, referred to as Mr B, did not want his son circumcised. He found out a few days afterward, while he was looking after the boy, and phoned Mehat to complain on October 22, the lawyer presenting the GMC's case said. His complaint started the GMC's investigation.

The next day, the lawyer said, the father called the doctor again to tell him he had taken his son to the emergency department at Royal Derby Hospital in the middle of the night because the boy was "in agony." "The Plastibell had migrated and there was an infection," the lawyer said.

The father told the hearing that the doctor should have checked whether he had consented too. "There could be conflicting opinions on circumcision, there could be differences in opinion, and therefore he should have done more thorough checks," he said.

Mehat said in his evidence that he had discussed parental responsibility with the mother on October 17, 2022, two days before the procedure, and that she told him no one else had it. His barrister, Ghazan Mahmood, argued that Mehat was "misled" by the mother and did not know the father also had parental responsibility.

The panel found Mehat's evidence "credible and reliable, supported by contemporaneous documentation." "She had signed the consent form, provided a birth certificate without a father's name and told Dr Mehat that she was not married," it said.

The consent form she signed stated: "All those with parental responsibility are aware of the procedure above to be carried out without any disagreement or disputes." The mother told the tribunal she had understood the form but signed it anyway.

The forms

The GMC had also alleged that Mehat "inappropriately" gave the mother two pre-prepared disclaimer forms and a pre-prepared statement, and asked her to sign and date them, the Nottingham Post reported.

The tribunal was "not satisfied" that he gave her a pre-prepared statement to sign after the circumcision. It found no sign that the forms were "intended to mislead or provide retrospective consent," and it found that the wrong date on one of the forms was a genuine error.

"Whilst having these forms completed prior to the procedure may have been best practise, and in line with the Practice's protocol, the Tribunal considered that it was not inappropriate or unprofessional for them to have been completed at a later date," the tribunal's chair said.

The GMC had also accused Mehat of not including the boy in the decision. His barrister said there was no case to answer, because the GMC had produced no evidence to support it. The tribunal agreed and removed that allegation.

An interim order that had restricted Mehat's practice was lifted after the ruling. The GMC's public register on Wednesday listed him as registered with a license to practice, with no conditions or interim order.

Guidance from the British Medical Association and the GMC says doctors should get consent from both parents, the BBC reported.

Earlier cases

It was the fourth medical tribunal Mehat had faced. In March 2019, he was suspended for one month after his fitness to practise was found impaired, because Nottingham City Council had cautioned him for numerous offenses relating to rental properties he owned.

In September 2019, he was suspended for one month for circumcising a baby without the mother's consent, which he admitted. According to that tribunal's written decision, the baby's grandparents had brought him in, and Mehat's unchallenged evidence was that he had been told the mother had agreed. It called the misconduct serious but a single lapse of judgment, and put the risk of repetition as very low.

In December 2024, he was given a warning for making derogatory comments about Muslim patients.

See something wrong? Report an error · How we correct pages