Does it matter who circumcises? Guinea study tracks injuries
Guinea study of 102 patients referred with circumcision complications: injuries were more often severe after traditional practitioners than after doctors.
By Circumpedia Staff
Published

Postcard: Comptoir Parisien, Conakry / Wikimedia Commons
Among patients referred to Guinea's national urology center with circumcision complications, three in four circumcised by traditional practitioners had severe injuries, against fewer than half of those circumcised by doctors, a 10-year study found.
The study, by researchers in the urology and general surgery departments of Ignace Deen University Hospital in Conakry, was published Friday in the African Journal of Urology. It looked back at the records of 102 patients the hospital's urology department saw from 2015 to 2024 for problems caused by an earlier circumcision. Their average age was 4.9 years. The youngest was 14 days old and the oldest 19.
The team counted four kinds of injury as severe because they need reconstructive surgery: a fistula, which is a hole between the tube urine comes out of (urethra) and the skin; loss of part of the head of the penis; loss of all of the head; and death of penile tissue. A narrowed urinary opening and slow healing counted as minor.
A fistula was the most common problem, seen in 46 patients (45.1%). In all, 55 patients (53.9%) had a severe injury.
Of the 29 patients circumcised by traditional practitioners, 75.9% had a severe injury. The share was 42.6% among the 54 circumcised by general practitioners, 46.2% among the 13 circumcised by nurses and 66.7% among the 6 circumcised by health technicians.
"Among complications referred to our centre, those occurring after circumcision by a traditional practitioner were more often severe," the authors wrote. "These results support the training and certification of operators, the strengthening of postoperative follow-up and community awareness."
Severe injuries were also more common among patients who had no care after the operation (71.1%, against 43.8% of those who did) and among those who reached the specialists more than 15 days after the problem began (also 71.1%, against 43.8%). Patients circumcised by traditional practitioners waited an average of 37 days after the problem began to reach the urology department, about twice as long as those circumcised by doctors (18.5 days). Age was not associated with severity in this series.
Circumcision is almost universal in Guinea, the authors wrote, and none of the four groups' training there includes a required circumcision-specific certification. They wrote that the doctors' severe share suggests the limits of general medical training for this procedure, and that its closeness to the nurses' share supports the view that a job title alone is an imperfect guide to a person's real skill. Preventing severe complications, they wrote, rests on a national training program with certification for those who circumcise, dedicated circumcision centers, closer follow-up after the operation and community awareness so families seek care sooner. They also wrote that clamps such as the Gomco and Mogen, or the Plastibell device in infants, are associated with fewer complications than freehand or guillotine techniques done without training.
The study has limits, which the authors set out. It included only patients who had a complication, and the number of circumcisions each group performed is unknown, so it cannot show how often a circumcision by any group goes wrong. Minor problems after traditional circumcision were probably referred less often, which may make the severe share in that group look higher. A job title stood in for actual training, the technique used was not always recorded, the delay measure mixed two different time spans, and the nurse and health technician groups were small.
The authors wrote that circumcision "performed under appropriate technical conditions is a safe procedure." The World Health Organization calls urethral fistula after circumcisions in HIV-prevention programs a "rare but serious" event, and a 2021 WHO technical brief sets out how to diagnose it, give first treatment and prevent it.
On Circumpedia: Who performs newborn and child circumcision · Newborn circumcision methods
See something wrong? Report an error · How we correct pages