Skip to main content

Can a boy refuse circumcision? South Africa's law says yes

A new legal analysis says South African school talks on medical circumcision can stay, but each boy must have his own say, in private.

A rapid HIV antibody test kit laid out on a clinic table

Photo: NIAID / Wikimedia Commons · CC BY 2.0

A South African boy recruited at school for medical circumcision has his own right to refuse at any age, and a parent's consent does not replace his say, a legal scholar has concluded.

Anathi Phela, of Mangosuthu University of Technology in Durban, made the case in a desk-based legal and ethical analysis published November 13 in BMC Medical Ethics. It examined the law, national and World Health Organization policy, and published studies. It did not survey boys.

"A boy's own participation is required, parental consent does not displace it, and the right to refuse applies at every age," Phela writes.

The right is in South Africa's Children's Act of 2005. "Taking into consideration the child's age, maturity and stage of development, every male child has the right to refuse circumcision," section 12(10) says.

The same section bans the circumcision of boys under 16, except for religious purposes or for medical reasons on a doctor's recommendation. A boy older than 16 can be circumcised only if he consents himself, after proper counseling.

Phela reads these lines together with the Act's general rules on children's consent. It is one scholar's reading, not a court ruling or a change in policy. "To my knowledge, the interpretation of ss 12 and 129 has not been settled by a court," Phela writes.

Where the risk sits

Published South African school programs describe adolescent-friendly services, with assent from boys under 16, Phela found. One of them, described in a 2014 study by the program's own researchers, reached out in 2011 to all 42 high schools in Vulindlela, a rural area of KwaZulu-Natal. There were talks at school assemblies and in Life Orientation classes. Later, student peer recruiters booked appointments for fellow students and arranged their transport. Teachers acted as go-betweens and were not actively involved in recruiting.

In two years, 5,165 circumcisions were done, the Vulindlela researchers reported. The median age was 16, and 728 were boys aged 12 to 14. Boys under 16 needed a parent's written consent and also gave their own statement of assent. The researchers judged their service feasible, acceptable and safe, Phela's paper notes.

Peer recruiters received small prizes, such as watches and T-shirts, and phone airtime worth no more than about $3 per recruiter, and the best performers won medals and trophies. The researchers said they aimed to reward recruiters "in a way that did not lead to coercion of adolescents." The study describes no rewards for the boys themselves, apart from transport.

Coercive and incentive-driven recruitment has been documented in Kenya, Phela writes, but not, in the sources found, in South Africa.

The paper places the greatest risk not in the classroom talk but later. "Collective education must be separated from individual enrolment and consent; voluntariness is most at risk at sign-up and counselling," the paper says.

Why programs reach boys early

Voluntary medical male circumcision, or VMMC, lowers men's risk of getting HIV from female partners by roughly 50 to 60% in relative terms, the paper says, and South Africa's program reaches adolescents.

"The public-health case supports early access for adolescents but does not by itself justify group-based sign-up of younger boys without safeguards," Phela writes.

The paper proposes school talks for information only, with no names, show of hands or bookings taken in the session. Each boy would be counseled in private, with a parent and also alone, and his own agreement recorded, not only a parent's form. A medical recommendation would be made for each boy under 16. There would be no payments for signing up, recruiters' pay would not be tied to numbers, and confidential checks would ask whether boys understood and felt free to say no.

"The concern is implementation risk and ethical design rather than unlawful policy," the paper concludes.

The paper does not say any South African school program broke the law. It says school talks can stay, as long as each boy decides in private and has his own say.

See something wrong? Report an error · How we correct pages