Skip to main content

Vitamin K and circumcision: what the studies show

More US babies skip the vitamin K shot, and a big study links that to more bleeding. Evidence on vitamin K and circumcision is limited.

A small amber glass ampoule of vitamin K1 injection with a red top, lying on a white surface
An ampoule of vitamin K1 (phytomenadione) for injection.

Photo: LHcheM / Wikimedia Commons · CC BY-SA 3.0

Missing the vitamin K shot at birth was linked to a 47% higher adjusted risk of a group of bleeding diagnoses in a baby's first six months, a study of 5.2 million US newborns has found.

The study, published November 5 in JAMA, was led by Dr. Kristan Scott, a neonatologist (newborn specialist) now at Emory University. It looked back at a large database of US hospital records, in which the share of babies who did not get the shot rose from 3.1% in 2017 to 6.8% in 2025.

Among babies who missed the shot, 288 in every 10,000 had bleeding recorded in their first six months, compared with 186 in every 10,000 who got it. Bleeding inside the skull was 33 versus 13 in every 10,000.

"The findings reinforce the longstanding recommendation that newborns receive the one-time intramuscular vitamin K injection," Scott said, as quoted by Scripps News.

The study's main outcome was not specifically bleeding after newborn circumcision, and its summary does not mention circumcision. That outcome was a group of bleeding diagnoses recorded from birth through six months: bleeding in or around the brain, newborn bleeding and vitamin K deficiency bleeding. The researchers had no data on the exact timing of each bleed, how bad it was or what caused it. And because the study looked back at records, it shows a link, not proof that the missing shot caused the bleeding.

A 1960 trial and ten babies

Pediatric urologists at NYU Langone Hospital–Long Island reviewed the medical research on circumcising newborns who did not get the shot, in a review published online in December 2024 in the Journal of Pediatric Urology.

One trial they describe is from 1960. Half of the boys in one newborn nursery were randomly chosen to get vitamin K on arrival. They had a sixfold drop in bleeding after circumcision compared with the boys who did not.

The review's authors say that result is hard to apply today. The babies were, on average, just over a day old, when a key clotting protein (prothrombin) was likely quite low. The review says a newborn's prothrombin drops after birth, is lowest at about one to three days, then recovers.

The newest cases in the review are the authors' own. From January to December 2024, they circumcised ten boys whose parents had refused the shot. The boys were 14 days old, and none got vitamin K by mouth either. None of the ten had extra bleeding, during the operation or afterwards, the authors reported.

It was a small report of ten cases, with no comparison group. The authors called for more research, including randomized trials, and still recommend the shot as the standard.

A 2025 clinical perspective in the journal Urology, based on a review of earlier research, says that, with counseling and backup plans ready, a safe circumcision is possible for carefully chosen babies who did not get the shot.

A 2013 case report from Botswana, also described in the review, shows the other side. A baby circumcised at two days old, during a clinical trial of early infant circumcision, bled for more than 90 minutes. The team then found he had not had the standard preventive vitamin K. Within 30 minutes of a vitamin K injection, the bleeding stopped.

The guidance

The American Academy of Pediatrics has recommended a single shot of vitamin K at birth since 1961, and every newborn is expected to get it, the CDC says. Babies who do not get it are 81 times more likely to develop late vitamin K deficiency bleeding.

In most cases of this bleeding, there are no warning signs before a life-threatening event starts, the CDC says. The signs it lists include bruises around the head and face, bleeding from the nose or umbilical cord, and blood in the stool.

The American Urological Association gives no specific guidance on vitamin K and circumcision, the review found. It also reported that, at the time, five other bodies, including the UK's NHS and the World Health Organization, lacked clear guidelines on the safety of circumcising newborns with or without vitamin K.

At Children's Hospital of Philadelphia, doctors wrote in 2023 that bleeding is one of the most common complications of circumcision. "This risk increases significantly when the child is past the neonatal period or has not received vitamin K," they wrote. "For this reason, our current policy requires verification that vitamin K was administered before a circumcision is performed."

When parents refuse the shot, the NYU Langone authors suggest doctors may consider circumcising within 24 hours of birth, while the mother's vitamin K is still in the baby's blood, or after day eight, when the baby's own clotting protein has recovered. They also recommend vitamin K by mouth as an alternative. It is their suggestion, not an official guideline.

Jewish ritual circumcision often takes place on the eighth day, performed by a mohel. The authors note that this timing coincides with the recovery of that clotting protein seen in an older study of babies without vitamin K.

See something wrong? Report an error · How we correct pages