Newborn circumcision methods: Gomco, Mogen, Plastibell
Short answer
The three most common methods of newborn circumcision are the Gomco clamp, the Mogen clamp and the Plastibell ring.1 All three are established methods, and the provider's training and experience help decide which one is used.1 The main difference at home is that the Plastibell leaves a plastic ring on the penis, which falls off by itself.1, 2
Below, all four methods side by side, including the traditional shield: how each works, how long it takes and how to care for him afterward.
For men 18 and over, see Adult circumcision methods and styles. Everything on babies and boys up to 17 starts at Circumcision in babies and children.

Illustration: Ryan Margolin, in Gologram M, Margolin R, Lomiguen CM, Cureus 2022 · CC BY
Key takeaways
- A Gomco clamp takes up to 10 minutes, a Mogen clamp less than 5 minutes, and a Plastibell up to 10 minutes.1
- The Plastibell ring stays on after the circumcision and usually falls off by itself in 5 to 10 days.4, 6
- Every newborn should get pain relief, whatever the method; a numbing injection (nerve block) is recommended.1
- Home care follows your provider's instructions for the method used; don't pull a Plastibell ring off, because that can cause bleeding.2
- A Plastibell ring that has moved down onto the shaft of the penis needs a call to your provider right away.2
At a glance
- Age covered
- Newborns
- Methods covered (alphabetical)
- Gomco clamp, Mogen clamp, Plastibell ring, traditional shield (magen)
- What they share
- All remove the foreskin; every newborn should get pain relief
- Main difference
- At home, the Plastibell leaves a ring that falls off by itself
- Who usually decides
- The provider; training and experience help decide the method
On this page
- What are the types of newborn circumcision?
- What's the difference between Gomco, Mogen, Plastibell and the shield?
- How does the Gomco clamp work?
- How does the Mogen clamp work?
- How does a Plastibell work?
- What is the traditional shield (magen)?
- Which method is used, and who decides?
- What pain relief is used with each method?
- How do I care for my baby after each method?
What are the types of newborn circumcision?
The three most common types of newborn circumcision are the Gomco clamp, the Mogen clamp and the Plastibell ring.1 All three remove the foreskin: the two clamps come off at the end, while the Plastibell leaves a plastic ring on that falls off by itself.1 The table also lists the traditional shield, which the medical sources on this page don't describe.
Newborn circumcision methods (babies in the first weeks of life). Methods are listed in alphabetical order. Times are for the whole procedure.
| Method | How it works | How long the procedure takes | Left on afterward? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gomco clamp | A metal bell covers the head of the penis; a clamp presses the foreskin against it, then the skin is removed1 | Up to 10 minutes1 | No1 |
| Mogen clamp | The foreskin is pulled into a narrow clamp, held for a minute or so, then cut away1 | Less than 5 minutes1 | No1 |
| Plastibell ring | A plastic ring goes under the foreskin; a string is tied around it and the skin beyond it is trimmed1 | Up to 10 minutes1 | Yes: the ring, until it falls off by itself1, 2 |
| Traditional shield (magen) | Not in our medical sources (see Practical experience) | Not in our medical sources (see Practical experience) | Not in our medical sources (see Practical experience) |
Gomco clamp
Mogen clamp
Plastibell ring
Traditional shield (magen)
- How it works
- Not in our medical sources (see Practical experience)
- How long the procedure takes
- Not in our medical sources (see Practical experience)
- Left on afterward?
- Not in our medical sources (see Practical experience)
What's the difference between Gomco, Mogen, Plastibell and the shield?
The Gomco and the Mogen are metal clamps that come off at the end of the circumcision.1 The Gomco uses a bell over the head of the penis and presses the foreskin for a few minutes.1 The Mogen holds the foreskin in a narrow clamp for a minute or so.1 The Plastibell is different: its plastic ring stays on until it falls off by itself, usually in 5 to 10 days.4, 6 The traditional shield isn't described in the medical sources on this page; see What is the traditional shield (magen)?.
How does the Gomco clamp work?
The Gomco clamp uses a metal bell and a clamp to hold the foreskin while it is removed.1

- How it works: A metal bell goes over the head of the penis. A clamp presses the foreskin against it for a few minutes before the skin is removed.1
- How long it takes: Up to 10 minutes.1
- Left on afterward: Nothing; the clamp comes off at the end.1
- Who usually uses it: Hospital doctors.3
- Things to know: Babies are watched for bleeding for at least 30 minutes after a clamp.3
How does the Mogen clamp work?
The Mogen clamp holds the foreskin in a narrow metal clamp while the skin is cut away.1

- How it works: The foreskin is pulled into a narrow clamp, held for a minute or so, and the skin is cut away.1
- How long it takes: Less than 5 minutes.1
- Left on afterward: Nothing; the clamp comes off at the end.1
- Who usually uses it: Hospital doctors.3
- Things to know: Babies are watched for bleeding for at least 30 minutes after a clamp.3
How does a Plastibell work?
A Plastibell is a plastic ring that stays on the penis after the circumcision and falls off by itself.1, 2

- How it works: A plastic ring goes under the foreskin, and a string is tied around it. The skin beyond the string is trimmed, and the ring's handle is snapped off.1
- How long it takes: Up to 10 minutes.1
- Left on afterward: The ring, until it falls off by itself.1, 2
- Who usually uses it: Hospital doctors.3
- Things to know: Don't pull the ring off; pulling it off can cause bleeding.2
When does the Plastibell ring fall off?
The Plastibell ring usually falls off by itself in 5 to 10 days. Call your provider if it's still on after 10 days.4, 6 Don't pull it off; pulling it off can cause bleeding.2
What's normal while the ring is on?
While the Plastibell ring is on, the penis is swollen for a few days, and a few drops of blood can be normal.2 Call your provider right away if the ring has moved down onto the shaft of the penis.2
What should I do after the Plastibell falls off?
Keep cleaning gently with warm water at each diaper change until the area has healed.2 Use petroleum jelly only if your provider tells you to.4 Where the ring was, the skin may look red, with some crusting or yellow patches, for a few days; this is usually normal.
What is the traditional shield (magen)?
The medical sources on this page describe the three devices but not the traditional shield, so what this section says about the shield comes from practical experience.

- How it works: Not in our medical sources (see Practical experience).
- How long it takes: Not in our medical sources (see Practical experience).
- Left on afterward: Not in our medical sources (see Practical experience).
- Who usually uses it: Not in our medical sources (see Practical experience).
- Things to know: Ask which pain relief the mohel uses, and how long he watches for bleeding afterward.
In practice, Orthodox mohels use the traditional shield (magen) and don't use clamps, for religious reasons. In practice, some mohels use a Mogen clamp, especially outside Orthodox communities or for families who aren't Jewish. In practice, with the shield, the cut takes only seconds.8
In practice, pain relief differs between mohels, and not all use the same method. In practice, many mohels doing a traditional circumcision with the shield don't give an injection and use another kind of numbing instead. Ask the mohel what he uses.8
Is the traditional shield the same as the Mogen clamp?
No. The Mogen clamp is a metal clamp.1 The foreskin is slid into it, the clamp is closed for 60 to 90 seconds, and the extra skin is cut away.1
In practice, the traditional shield is a flat metal guard with a narrow slit that protects the head of the penis while the foreskin is cut. In practice, the shield isn't left clamped on.8
Which method is used, and who decides?
There's no single best method. All three hospital devices are established methods, and the provider's training and experience help decide which one is used.1 Hospital doctors mostly use one of the three devices: the Gomco clamp, the Mogen clamp or the Plastibell.3
Ask your provider which method they use and why. Who does newborn and child circumcision? explains each type of provider, from family doctors to mohels, and how to check one.
What pain relief is used with each method?
Pain relief should be given to every newborn, whatever the method.1 A numbing injection at the base of the penis (nerve block) is recommended. Numbing cream (put on 30 to 60 minutes before) and sugar water can be added, but they shouldn't replace the injection.1 Ask what pain relief will be used. For the traditional shield, see the pain-relief Practical experience box in What is the traditional shield (magen)?.
Newborn circumcision explains pain relief during and after the circumcision in more detail.
How do I care for my baby after each method?
After a Gomco or Mogen clamp or the shield, petroleum jelly is often put on at each diaper change; if your provider recommends it, use it for as long as they tell you.6 With a Plastibell, ask your provider before using petroleum jelly.2, 4 After any method, clean gently with warm water, not wipes; mild soapy water can be used if stool gets on the penis, following your provider's instructions.6
Does healing differ by method?
Not known: the sources on this page don't compare healing between the methods. The main difference afterward is the Plastibell ring, which stays on until it falls off by itself.1, 2
For healing time and what's normal day by day, see How long does a newborn circumcision take to heal?. For skin that sticks to the head of the penis later, see Penile adhesions, skin bridges and revision in boys.
When to call
Call 911 now
Call your provider today
- A fever of 100.4°F (38°C) or higher: call your provider right away or go to the emergency department for immediate evaluation6
- The head of the penis looks dark blue or black: go to the emergency department right away2
- Severe pain: call your provider right away or go to the emergency department for immediate evaluation6
- Right away if there's unusual sleepiness, or poor feeding with signs of illness
- Right away if bleeding is more than a few drops, or there's a bloodstain on the diaper bigger than a quarter2, 7
- Right away if there's no wet diaper within 6 to 8 hours6, 7
- Right away if he can't urinate, or passes only a few drops of urine, even before 6 to 8 hours
- Right away if redness or swelling gets worse, including severe swelling of the penis, or redness spreads, or you see pus or pimples2, 6
- Right away if the Plastibell ring has moved down onto the shaft of the penis2
- Right away if he cries and can't be comforted for more than 2 hours2
- Right away if the edges of the wound come apart, even without much bleeding
- Redness or swelling that doesn't go away6
- Yellow crust that lasts more than a week7
- The Plastibell ring is still on after 10 days4, 6
- The skin slides back over the head of the penis and sticks5
Questions to ask your provider
- Which method do you use, and why?
- How long does it take?
- What pain relief do you use?
- If it's a Plastibell, what should we do while the ring is on?
- What happens if there's bleeding afterward? Can we reach you directly, including at night?
The bottom line
Each newborn method removes the foreskin in its own way, and each comes with its own aftercare, especially the Plastibell ring. Ask your son's provider which method they use and why, what pain relief they give, and what to watch for afterward.
Sources (8)
- Omole F, Smith W, Carter-Wicker K. "Newborn Circumcision Techniques." American Family Physician 2020;101(11):680-685. American Academy of Family Physicians. Jun 1, 2020. https://www.aafp.org/pubs/afp/issues/2020/0601/p680.html (accessed Oct 26, 2026)
- Seattle Children's. "Circumcision Problems." Reviewed May 6, 2025. https://www.seattlechildrens.org/conditions/a-z/circumcision-problems/ (accessed Oct 26, 2026)
- Warees MW, Anand S, Leslie SW, Rodriguez AM. "Circumcision." StatPearls, NCBI Bookshelf (NBK535436). Updated May 2, 2024. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK535436/ (accessed Oct 26, 2026)
- Nemours KidsHealth. "After Circumcision With a Plastibell: How to Care for Your Baby." Created Jul 26, 2023 (no reviewed date). https://khpi.kidshealth.org/en/parent/1991.html (accessed Oct 26, 2026)
- Stanford Medicine Newborn Nursery. "Complications of Circumcision." Jun 7, 2016. https://med.stanford.edu/newborns/professional-education/circumcision/complications.html (accessed Oct 26, 2026)
- Nemours KidsHealth. "Circumcision" (for parents). Reviewed May 2026. https://kidshealth.org/en/parents/circumcision.html (accessed Oct 26, 2026)
- Nemours KidsHealth. "After Circumcision: How to Care for Your Baby." Created May 8, 2018 (©2026). https://khpi.kidshealth.org/en/parent/1553.html (accessed Oct 26, 2026)
- Practical experience of a circumcision specialist
See something wrong? Report an error · How we correct pages · How we make our pages