Skip to main content

Boy circumcised without father's consent, UK tribunal hears

The short version

A Nottingham doctor circumcised a 7-year-old boy without asking his views and without his father's consent, a UK medical tribunal has heard, the BBC reported. Dr Balvinder Mehat faces a misconduct case over the procedure. The General Medical Council's case also alleges that he asked the boy's mother to sign a backdated disclaimer form after the father complained. The tribunal has not ruled, and the hearing is expected to take about two weeks.

A Plastibell, the small plastic ring with a string used in one circumcision method, on a black background

Photo: Dan Bollinger / Wikimedia Commons · CC BY-SA 4.0

Update, November 17, 2026: The tribunal has since found that Dr Mehat's actions did not amount to misconduct, and he can continue to practice, the BBC reported. Read our story on the ruling.

What is the doctor accused of?

The UK's medical regulator, the General Medical Council (GMC), investigated the case and referred Dr Mehat to a hearing of the Medical Practitioners Tribunal Service (MPTS), the BBC reported on November 3.

The tribunal heard that Dr Mehat, a GP, circumcised the boy, known as Patient A, at Bakersfield Medical Centre in Nottingham on October 19, 2022. His mother took him there because she wanted the circumcision for "spiritual and cultural reasons."

The boy has mixed heritage. His Zimbabwean mother wanted him circumcised, but his father did not. The parents married in 2019 and had separated by the time of the procedure, said Alan Taylor, the lawyer presenting the GMC's case.

The mother gave Dr Mehat a copy of the boy's birth certificate, which did not name the father. She also signed a consent form that left him off. She gave no details about the father's role in the boy's life or whether he knew about the procedure, Taylor told the tribunal.

The GMC's case also alleges that Dr Mehat asked the mother to sign a disclaimer form on October 24, 2022, after he had carried out the procedure, and another on December 8, backdated to October 19. None of the allegations has been proven.

What happened after the circumcision?

The father learned about the circumcision a few days later, while he was looking after his son, and phoned Dr Mehat on October 22 to complain, Taylor told the tribunal.

On October 23, the father called Dr Mehat again to say he had taken his son to the emergency department at Royal Derby Hospital in the middle of the night "because he was in agony," Taylor said. "The Plastibell had migrated and there was an infection." (A Plastibell is a plastic ring used in one circumcision method; see newborn circumcision methods.)

What do the rules say?

GMC guidance says doctors should get consent from both parents before circumcising a child, the BBC reported.

The GMC asked a pediatric surgeon, Simon Clarke, to report on Dr Mehat's actions. His report said that when a child arrives with only one parent, the doctor "must make every effort to contact the other parent" to seek consent.

Clarke also said children should take part in decisions about their care "as much as possible." He found no evidence that anyone had asked Patient A for his opinion, and said Dr Mehat had not involved the boy in the decision.

The father, referred to as Mr B, told the hearing that Dr Mehat should have checked whether he had consented too. He said the doctor should have paid closer attention to the boy's welfare and safeguarding because the boy's name and heritage differed from his mother's, and should have done "more thorough checks."

Has the doctor faced a tribunal before?

Yes. This is Dr Mehat's fourth medical tribunal, the BBC reported:

  • March 2019: a tribunal suspended him for one month after finding his "fitness to practise" impaired, because Nottingham City Council had cautioned him for numerous offenses relating to rental properties he owned.
  • September 2019: a tribunal suspended him for one month for circumcising a baby without the mother's consent, an allegation he admitted at the hearing. It found a "very low risk of repetition" and let him keep working. He said in a statement to the BBC at the time that he was "very regretful" and would write a letter of apology. In 2017, prosecutors had decided to take no further action over that case.
  • December 2024: a tribunal gave him a warning for making derogatory comments about Muslim patients.

What isn't known yet?

  • What the tribunal will decide. It is also due to hear evidence from the boy's mother.
  • How Dr Mehat answers the allegations at this hearing. The BBC's report did not include a response from him. Earlier, when the GMC decided to look at the case again, Eastern Eye reported that he said he would cooperate and that he had carried out the procedure correctly after getting appropriate consent.

What it means

The tribunal is still hearing evidence and has made no findings. GMC guidance says both parents should consent to a child's circumcision, and the GMC's expert said children should take part in decisions about their care as far as possible. For how and by whom children are circumcised, see who performs newborn and child circumcision.

Original reports and sources (5)
  1. BBC News, Caroline Lowbridge, "Doctor circumcised boy 'without seeking his opinion'," November 3, 2026, https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c65yne4j1vjro (read November 6, 2026)
  2. BBC News, "'No consent' circumcision doctor suspended for a month," October 11, 2019, https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-nottinghamshire-50015900 (read November 6, 2026)
  3. BBC News, "GP Balvinder Mehat made derogatory comments about Muslim patients," December 20, 2024, https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cx2p92q5992o (read November 6, 2026)
  4. Eastern Eye, "Doctor faces inquiry for circumcising boy without adequate consent," undated, https://easterneye.biz/doctor-balvinder-mehat-faces-gmc-inquiry (read November 6, 2026)
  5. BBC News, Caroline Lowbridge, "Doctor was 'misled' by circumcised boy's mother," November 17, 2026, https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cx24enz2l06yo (read November 17, 2026)

See something wrong? Report an error · How we correct pages