Skip to main content

Oregon judge throws out suit to ban boys' circumcision

The short version

Multnomah County Circuit Judge Melvin Oden-Orr has dismissed a lawsuit challenging Oregon's different legal treatment of male and female genital cutting, finding that the three plaintiffs lacked standing. The plaintiffs' lawyer said they intend to appeal. The ruling did not resolve the underlying constitutional dispute.

The entrance of the Multnomah County Central Courthouse in Portland, Oregon, for the story on the circumcision lawsuit

Photo: Steve Morgan / Wikimedia Commons · CC BY-SA 4.0

Why did the judge dismiss the case?

Oden-Orr granted summary judgment in favor of Oregon on September 28, 2026, according to The Oregonian/OregonLive. The decision ended the lawsuit at the trial-court level without a trial.

Rather than deciding whether the state's genital-cutting laws violate constitutional protections, the judge considered whether the three plaintiffs had the legal standing required to challenge the state.

Oden-Orr said the state couldn't be liable because it didn't directly harm the plaintiffs, and he questioned the remedy they sought, The Oregonian reported.

"Plaintiffs fail to point to the practical effect the decision will have on Plaintiffs themselves, only some hypothetical male minors not before the Court," he wrote. "Or that a decision of this Court will (undo) Plaintiffs' circumcisions and/or any related stigma."

His written order said: "no objectively reasonable juror could return a verdict in (the plaintiffs') favor. … Therefore, the Court finds they lack standing, there is no justiciable controversy and Defendant is entitled to prevail as a matter of law," The Oregonian reported.

The ruling addressed the plaintiffs' authority to bring the lawsuit, not whether circumcision itself is lawful or medically appropriate.

Who filed the lawsuit?

The three plaintiffs named in the September 2026 reporting were Dane Hadachek, Nathaniel Hellewell and Landon Moody, all of whom had been circumcised.

The lawsuit, filed in 2025 on behalf of circumcised men, challenged Oregon's legal protections against genital cutting. Oregon enacted a prohibition on female genital mutilation involving children in 1999. The plaintiffs argued that excluding boys from comparable protection amounted to sex discrimination under the state constitution. They sought either to extend those protections to children regardless of sex or to invalidate the existing law.

Their complaint said every child has a right to bodily integrity and that "every person also has a right to the equal protection of the law regardless of biological sex," Law&Crime reported. The lawsuit also argued that circumcision provides no medical benefits, The Oregonian reported.

The men's lead lawyer, Eric Clopper, told The Oregonian in 2025: "They suffered stigmatic harm by being treated as lesser than, or be given less legal rights, because of their sex." He and local lawyer Lake Perriguey described the case as the first in a multi-state effort to restrict or ban circumcision.

How did Oregon defend its law?

In 2025, lawyers for the Oregon Department of Justice argued that Oregon never required circumcision and that changes to state law should come from the Legislature, not a judge, The Oregonian reported.

"The purpose of this lawsuit is not to address actual harm faced by these plaintiffs, but to use this case as a springboard for legislative reform," Assistant Attorney General Kate Morrow wrote in a 2025 filing. She argued that the men had only an "abstract, speculative" interest in changing the law and therefore weren't qualified to sue.

Department spokesperson Jenny Hansson said in a 2025 statement that the department is defending the law because it protects "young girls and women from horrific practices." She added: "ODOJ will continue to defend the law to prevent female genital mutilation from occurring in Oregon."

The Oregon Department of Justice building in Salem, for the story on the state's defence of the circumcision lawsuit
Photo: Gary Halvorson / Oregon State Archives / Wikimedia Commons · CC BY 4.0

What have medical and religious groups said?

The Oregonian reported in 2025 that the American Academy of Pediatrics determined in 2012 that circumcision's health benefits outweigh the risks but that "health benefits are not great enough to recommend" the procedure routinely.

The same report said that, while its acceptance in the medical establishment has receded somewhat in recent years, circumcision remains an important practice for certain Jewish and Muslim faith communities. These broader questions were not decided in Oden-Orr's September ruling.

Why had the lawsuit been allowed to continue earlier?

The same judge had declined an earlier request to dismiss the case. In October 2025, Oden-Orr found at that preliminary stage that the plaintiffs had standing, which allowed discovery, when the two sides exchange evidence. After the later summary-judgment proceedings, he reached a different conclusion.

Will the plaintiffs appeal?

Clopper said his clients intend to appeal. "The important point is that the Court did not decide the merits of our constitutional challenge," he told The Oregonian/OregonLive in an email. "The Court's ruling should not be understood as an endorsement of circumcision or as a determination that boys are entitled to less protection. Those issues were simply not decided."

In an Oct. 2 statement posted by GALDEF, an advocacy group, Intact Global said it had "already started the appeal process." We could not confirm in court records or news reports that a notice of appeal has been filed, as of November 4, 2026.

What remains uncertain?

  • Whether a notice of appeal has been filed.
  • Whether the Oregon Department of Justice has commented on the September ruling. We found no comment.
  • Whether any court will rule on the main question: does Oregon's genital mutilation law treat boys and girls unequally?

What it means

Oregon's existing laws remain unchanged after the dismissal. The judge found that these plaintiffs could not pursue their challenge. He did not decide whether Oregon's different legal protections for boys and girls violate the state constitution.

Original reports and sources (6)
  1. Todd T. "Judge rejects lawsuit seeking to ban circumcision in Oregon." The Oregonian/OregonLive. September 30, 2026. https://www.oregonlive.com/crime/2026/09/judge-rejects-lawsuit-seeking-to-ban-circumcision-in-oregon.html
  2. Sparling Z. "Lawsuit seeking to ban circumcision as discriminatory genital cutting passes crucial legal test." The Oregonian/OregonLive. October 2025. https://www.oregonlive.com/pacific-northwest-news/2025/10/lawsuit-seeking-to-ban-circumcision-as-discriminatory-genital-cutting-passes-crucial-legal-test.html
  3. Law&Crime. "Lawsuit seeking to ban circumcision gets thrown out by judge." October 2, 2026. https://lawandcrime.com/lawsuit/lawsuit-seeking-to-ban-circumcision-arguing-it-robs-boys-of-bodily-autonomy-and-gives-parents-nightmares-gets-thrown-out-by-judge/
  4. GALDEF. "Special Update: Hadachek v. Oregon." October 5, 2026. https://www.galdef.org/2026/10/05/special-update-hadachek-v-oregon/
  5. Oregon Department of Justice, https://www.doj.state.or.us/ (organization link)
  6. American Academy of Pediatrics, https://www.aap.org/ (organization link)

See something wrong? Report an error · How we correct pages