Skip to main content

Converting to marry: a comic's adult circumcision on stage

Comedian Max Olesker had to be circumcised as an adult to convert to Orthodox Judaism and marry. He turned it into a memoir and a London stage show.

The front of Soho Theatre on Dean Street in London, where Max Olesker's show Making the Cut is running

Photo: Ewan Munro / Wikimedia Commons · CC BY-SA 2.0

British comedian Max Olesker had to be circumcised as an adult to convert to Orthodox Judaism and marry, and his stage show about the experience opened in London on November 3, The Guardian reported.

Olesker, 38, met Eliana at the Edinburgh Festival Fringe. He had grown up identifying as Jewish, but his mother's earlier conversion had taken place within a less strict branch of Judaism, and the Beth Din, the rabbinical court overseeing his Orthodox conversion, did not recognize it as sufficient.

Marrying Eliana therefore required a formal Orthodox conversion, including circumcision as an adult.

In the interview, he described the experience as "extraordinarily challenging" and said the prolonged process placed considerable strain on the relationship. Olesker said his intention was not to attack the rabbis, but to communicate the distress he experienced.

He kept a journal during the conversion, including periods when anxiety made sleeping difficult.

The show, Making the Cut, is adapted from his memoir, Making the Cut: An Unorthodox Love Story, published by Ebury, part of Penguin. While its title refers to circumcision, it explores more than the procedure, following his relationship, his religious identity and the emotional demands of the conversion.

Olesker described performing it as "both draining and energising," and said the material sometimes became difficult to deliver without becoming emotional.

The production played the Edinburgh Festival Fringe, where it was categorized as theater rather than comedy. Soho Theatre in London lists performances through January 9, 2027, with none listed between November 21 and December 14, or between December 23 and January 4. The theater lists a running time of 60 minutes. Tom Parry directs. Olesker is one half of the comedy partnership Max & Ivan, with Ivan Gonzalez.

Reviewing the show for LondonTheatre1 on November 6, Alan Fitter gave it five stars and called Olesker "a terrific storyteller, mixing laugh-out-loud comedy with genuine emotional weight."

For men, an Orthodox conversion "always requires" immersion in a mikveh (ritual bath) and either brit milah, the circumcision ritual, or, for a man already circumcised, the ritual taking of a drop of blood (hatafat dam brit), according to a guide on My Jewish Learning. In Reform Judaism, the guide says, the individual rabbi decides whether circumcision is required, strongly encouraged or optional.

On Circumpedia: Why adults get circumcised · What is circumcision?

See something wrong? Report an error · How we correct pages