"We must see and touch evidence": elders' circumcision check
A Kenyan elders' council is checking its 3,674 registered elders for proof of circumcision at shrines. A lecturer says the constitution forbids it.

Photo: AmateurMaestro / Wikimedia Commons · CC BY-SA 4.0
A Kenyan elders' council has begun checking the 3,674 elders on its register for proof of circumcision in a 100-day exercise, its national patron, Kung'u Muigai, told the Daily Nation in October.
The check was approved at an extraordinary meeting of the Kiama Kia Ma council attended by 63 elders, held on September 28 in Kiambu County, Muigai said. Under the plan, chosen elders already confirmed as circumcised and the men undergoing verification are to show each other their genitals at shrines across the Mt Kenya region.
"We must see and touch evidence of circumcision," Muigai said.
"We must ensure that, going forward, we have 100 per cent conformity to the knife," he said. "We cannot continue assuming that when we are together, all of us are circumcised."
He maintained that the check will be voluntary, discreet, and humane, and that, from now on, every elder who wants to join the councils will first be subjected to this verification. Any elder who fails to appear will be removed from the register and treated as a suspect, Muigai said.
A lecturer objects
Simon Okumba Miruka, a South Eastern Kenya University lecturer specializing in gender and development studies, objects to what he calls forced checks.
In a Daily Nation column on November 13, he cited Article 44(3) of Kenya's Constitution: "A person shall not compel another person to perform, observe or undergo any cultural practice or rite." He also cited Article 31, the right to privacy.
"Muigai and his circle cannot force anyone, notwithstanding that they belong to the same community, to undergo circumcision. Excluding non-compliant individuals is also discriminatory," he wrote.
340 cases, 146 found after death
For the past two decades, Muigai said, the council avoided facing the problem, opting to discreetly arrange circumcision for the elders it discovered. He calculates that around 340 cases of uncircumcised elders have come to light since 2010 and that 146 of them were discovered post-mortem.
These secrets come out through marital disputes, alcohol consumption, or when a health worker from the community accidentally reveals the truth during a hospital stay, he said.
In October, three Kiambu elders, aged 65, 68, and 74, were recovering at home after undergoing adult circumcision, while a 59-year-old man from Murang'a "is on the run after his wife reported him to us," Muigai said.
He also said that community members working in mortuaries make sure no uncircumcised man is buried uncut: "Our community members working in mortuaries cannot allow you to be buried until you posthumously face the knife."
Wachira Kiago, chairman of the Kikuyu Council of Elders, a separate body, put it this way: "Without circumcision in our community, we have no men."
He added: "We are now resorting to more humane but firm crackdowns – dialogue, family pressure, and seclusion – rather than outright violence, but the principle remains."
Joseph Kaguthi, convener of a council uniting Gikuyu, Embu, and Meru elders and clergy, said traditional customs prohibit an uncircumcised man from sitting on the elders' council, participating in decision-making, marrying, paying a dowry, or owning a homestead.
"An adult male who has not undergone circumcision is defined as a community misfit," he said.
The Star, another Kenyan newspaper, reported in October that elders had accused an unnamed member over 70 of conducting rites for years before his own circumcision.
"He got circumcised like five years ago. He was more than 70 years," Muigai said, while another unnamed elder added that the people who received rites from him "will need to be cleansed."
Not every elder sees the rite the same way. Mzee John Njue, an 82-year-old cultural historian from Embu, said circumcision has been losing its cultural significance in the region.
"When it became a business and even the churches started presiding over male circumcision, we lost it," he said. "Today, we have boys who are taken by their own mothers and sisters to get circumcised in hospitals."
See something wrong? Report an error · How we correct pages