Skip to main content

When should a bris wait? 100-plus mohels heard the doctors

More than 100 mohels met to hear a pediatric urologist, a pediatrician and rabbis on bris safety, and on when a baby's bris has to wait.

A circumcision knife with a pale carved handle lying in an open, velvet-lined wooden case
A circumcision knife from New Orleans, about 1930, in the collection of the Museum of the Southern Jewish Experience.

Photo: Oleg Yunakov / Wikimedia Commons · CC BY-SA 4.0

More than 100 mohels heard a New York pediatric urologist explain when a baby's bris can go ahead on the eighth day and when it should wait, CrownHeights.info and The Lakewood Scoop reported on November 10.

The urologist, Dr. Jeffrey Stock, chief of pediatric urology at Mount Sinai Kravis Children's Hospital, spoke at this year's annual Kinus Mohalim, organized by Rabbi Levi Heber, director of the International Bris Association. The mohels came from across the United States and around the world.

A mohel performs brit milah, the Jewish ritual of circumcision, traditionally on the eighth day after a boy's birth. A baby's health can decide whether the bris goes ahead that day.

In a separate article on Chabad.org, Heber writes that the ceremony is put off when a newborn is premature, weak or ill, or has a condition such as jaundice or an eye infection. "We wait for the child's full recovery before performing the circumcision," he writes. In certain cases, he adds, the bris waits seven full days after the baby recovers.

At the gathering, Stock discussed medical considerations in newborn circumcision. Dr. Avraham Polinger, a pediatrician, spoke about medical conditions mohels should recognize when they examine a newborn, and about the importance of communicating with the child's medical providers. Rabbi Tuvia Kasimov, rabbi of Empire Shul, gave the perspective of Jewish law.

Rabbi Dovid Shlomo Gelber, a mohel from Israel and an authority on the Jewish law of circumcision, shared practical techniques meant to make the bris safer and better, drawing on his experience and on studies conducted in Israel. A long question-and-answer session followed the talks.

Mohels often work independently in their communities, and the annual meeting gives them a chance to connect and exchange experience. Heber stressed unity and continued education, and access to a qualified mohel for every Jewish family.

The two accounts did not give the date or place of the gathering. They reported no new standard for mohels and no change in religious practice.

What Jewish law says about waiting

The eighth-day bris generally takes place even when that day is Shabbat, a festival or Yom Kippur, Rabbi Dr. Ari Zivotofsky wrote in the spring 2026 issue of Jewish Action. Illness is a major exception. "An infant who is sick is not circumcised until he recovers," the Mishnah rules, in the line he quotes.

Zivotofsky describes two kinds of illness. After a systemic illness, one that affects the whole body, the bris waits seven full days after the baby recovers. After a local problem, it should be done as soon as he has recovered. A doctor can be relied on to say which kind a condition is, he writes, but not to authorize a bris against an explicit religious rule.

Newborn jaundice, a yellow tone to a baby's skin, shows how the medical and religious answers can differ. Zivotofsky calls it a relatively common condition and writes that, in most doctors' view, physiologic jaundice, the kind in the overwhelming majority of cases, is usually no bar to circumcision. If the Talmud's "yellow" baby means jaundice, Jewish law delays the bris until the skin color returns to normal. Authorities differ on whether a further seven-day wait is needed, and at least one has held that the bris can still take place on the eighth day when the jaundice is the non-dangerous, physiologic kind.

On timing, his article says, a mohel should be consulted together with competent rabbinic and medical authorities.

Stock has met with the mohels before. He was on the panel at their 2024 gathering, and he received an award of appreciation at a roundtable in Crown Heights that COLlive reported in November 2025. That meeting covered in vitro fertilization and surrogacy, medical anomalies and treatments that can affect the procedure and vitamin K's role in blood clotting.

On Circumpedia: Who does newborn and child circumcision · Newborn circumcision

See something wrong? Report an error · How we correct pages